Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2: Which Is The Winner?

This blog will compare three popular tire models: Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2. Off-road enthusiasts know that choosing the right tires for their vehicle is crucial for a successful and safe outdoor adventure. The market is flooded with various brands and models, making it challenging to decide which one to go for.

Cooper ST Maxx is known for its exceptional off-road capabilities while providing drivers with a smooth on-road experience. Goodyear Duratrac, on the other hand, strikes a balance between ruggedness and comfort, providing excellent traction in all weather conditions.

Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2 Comparison Table:

All-terrain tires are popular for drivers who want to tackle various weather conditions, terrains, and surfaces. The Cooper ST Maxx, Goodyear Duratrac, and BFG KO2 are three of the most renowned models in this category, known for their superior performance in different areas. Selecting the right tire can be daunting without properly comparing their features.

One crucial aspect to consider when choosing an all-terrain tire is noise reduction. While all three models score well in this criterion, the Goodyear Duratrac stands out with its quiet and comfortable ride. Another factor that sets these tires apart is road performance. Here, the BFG KO2 takes the lead with its exceptional handling on wet and dry roads. Durability is an important consideration since all-terrain tires must withstand harsh driving conditions.

Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2: Detailed Analysis:

Cooper ST MaxxGoodyear DuratracBFG KO2
Off-road Performance5*34
On-road Performance345
Snow and Ice Performance354
Noise Level234
Comfort Level534
Treadwear WarrantyLimited Warranty50,000 miles50,000 miles
Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2

Off-road Performance:

Cooper ST Maxx:

Off-road performance, the Cooper ST Maxx stands out among the competition. This tire benefits from a wide tread that provides excellent grip and balance in various off-road terrains, including sand, dirt, rock, and mud. The Cooper ST Maxx also utilizes a unique 3-Armor-Tek3 construction that enhances its durability and treadwear. You can enjoy your off-road adventures without worrying about damaging your tires.

One of the features responsible for the superior off-road performance of this tire is the stone ejector feature. It efficiently removes debris from the tread, which is crucial when driving in rocky terrain. The abrasion-resistant compound used in its design also protects against cuts on rough trails. With other impressive features such as high mileage capability and low rolling resistance, you can be sure you will get maximum value for your money with this tire.

On-road Performance:


When buying all-terrain tires, finding a tire that can perform on and off the road is crucial. The wrong choice can result in discomfort during daily drives and poor performance in challenging terrains. Fortunately, some models combine exceptional off-roading ability with excellent on-road performance, providing an optimal driving experience.

Our review of the Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2 found that the BFG KO2 takes top honors regarding on-road performance. This tire performs well on wet and dry roads, which is notable because most reliable all-terrain tires have poor on-road performance. The BFG KO2 has low rolling resistance, making it an eco-friendly option that saves fuel while driving.

Snow and Ice Performance:

Goodyear Duratrac:

When considering all-terrain tires, many drivers focus on their ability to handle mud, sand, gravel, and rock. But what about winter roads? An all-terrain tire must navigate these conditions confidently in regions where snow and ice are common during the colder months. Goodyear’s Duratrac tire is a top performer in winter conditions, offering superior handling and steering capabilities in the snow and ice.

One key feature that sets the Duratrac apart from other tires is its TractiveGroove technology. This design increases grip and traction in snowy or icy conditions by creating more biting edges for the tire to grab onto. Goodyear designed the Duratrac with self-cleaning shoulder blocks that prevent snow from building up on the tire’s surface. This helps ensure drivers maintain control even in slippery or unpredictable driving conditions.

Noise Level:

 BFG KO2 (Least Noise):

Driving on rough terrain can be a thrilling experience, but it often comes with the downside of increased road noise. This is particularly true when using all-terrain tires designed for off-road use and, therefore, cannot match the quietness of road tires. There are still models offering reasonable noise levels for drivers prioritizing a smooth and peaceful ride. One tire that falls short in this regard is the Cooper ST Maxx, which ranked worst in our noise comparison among three popular options.

Experts believe that the super-aggressive tread design on the Cooper ST Maxx is largely responsible for its excessive noise levels. On the other hand, the Goodyear Duratrac fares better in quietness despite a slight increase in road noise as speed rises. The angled shoulder blocks on this tire may help to dampen some of the noise and create a more manageable driving experience.

Comfort Level:

The comfort level of your tire is not something to overlook when purchasing all-terrain tires. It plays a crucial role in the overall quality of your ride, especially if you plan on taking your vehicle off-road. The Cooper ST Maxx proves to be the best option for those searching for a comfortable ride. This tire adapts well to different road conditions and terrains, making it an excellent choice for those who value a smooth driving experience.

While the Goodyear Duratrac and BFG KO2 are decent options on pavement, they fall short in terms of comfort compared to the Cooper ST Maxx. Drivers should not fear that these tires will make their drive unbearable. These two options offer adequate comfort levels for most drivers but are less comfortable than the Cooper ST Maxx.

Treadwear Warranty:

Cooper Tire is a brand in the tire industry and for good reason. The company has built a reputation for producing durable, long-lasting tires that withstand harsh conditions. One of their most popular offerings is the Cooper ST Maxx tire, a favorite among off-road enthusiasts. This tire is designed to deliver exceptional performance on and off the road, making it a versatile choice for truck owners.

One of the standout features of the Cooper ST Maxx is its impressive lifespan. With an average lifespan of up to six years or 70,000 miles, these tires offer excellent value for money. It’s worth noting that Cooper’s treadwear warranty is somewhat limited compared to other brands.



Cooper Tire is a well-known brand producing high-quality, durable tires for many years. Their ST Maxx tire model is no exception to this reputation. With an average lifespan of up to six years or 70,000 miles, the ST Maxx is a reliable choice for drivers who want long-lasting tires.

While Cooper offers a limited treadwear warranty on their tires, it may not be as comprehensive as other brands. The company guarantees the materials and craftsmanship of 32-inch tread wear on the ST Maxx. Customers are entitled to a free tire replacement if any defects are found during this time. This can provide peace of mind for those who worry about potential tire issues.

Final Thoughts:

We have discussed Cooper ST Maxx vs. Goodyear Duratrac vs. BFG KO2. Each of these tires has its strengths and weaknesses. The Cooper ST Maxx offers excellent traction in mud and snow but is less comfortable on the highway. The Goodyear Duratrac provides superior grip on wet surfaces but can be noisy and lacks durability. The BFG KO2 is a well-rounded tire that performs admirably in all conditions, although it is not the best in any one area.


How do these tires compare in terms of performance?

The Cooper ST Maxx offers superior tread life and is generally less expensive and better than the other two options. The Goodyear Duratrac has excellent off-road performance and handles well in all types of terrain, including mud and snow. The BFG KO2 has excellent off-road performance with great traction in mud and snow.

Which is the best tire for my driving style?

It depends on your driving style and what type of terrain you are driving in. The Cooper ST Maxx is a great all-around tire that offers excellent traction and handling on wet and dry roads. The Goodyear Duratrac is designed for off-road use and provides great grip in mud, snow, and sand. The BFG KO2 is an all-terrain tire that performs well on paved roads and off-road trails.